Monday, April 2, 2012

Proper Language

The question of whether or not there is still such a thing as "proper" English in society today is a difficult one to answer. I was initially tempted to say "Absolutely, yes" but upon further contemplation, I wonder if it really still exists. I would say that it most likely does in the U.K., where education and therefore proper language is extremely valued, but I don't know if I would say the same for the U.S. Although the U.K. is probably now just as much of a melting pot as the U.S. is, I still think that because of America's history as an all-inclusive country, the U.S. would be more willing to stray from embracing "proper" English. So yes; in some sense, it exists, but it's relevance (because of the increase in technology, and therefore acronyms and slang) is declining. I would also say that proper English only deserves to be valued more than any other in academic settings, and certainly not in conversation.

Those who value one type of English do indeed silence others. Any immigrants or uneducated individuals who's style of speech is not necessarily "proper" would certainly feel subjugated and probably even disinclined to speak the language. I know that if I were in France, for instance, and was laughed at or constantly corrected, I would certainly become discouraged and probably silence myself. So yes; "proper" English does indeed silence some populations.

2 comments:

  1. The note at the end about immigrants is very good. It shows how this question can be related to real life events. This reference also makes me question if someone could argue that other forms of English silence just as formal English does.

    ReplyDelete
  2. While "proper" English may silence some populations, I believe they know that "proper" English is expected to be spoken before they come to this country. Also, I believe that as long as someone is speaking with "proper" grammar for the part of the world they come from, it is more valued if they were talking in slang or "butchering" another language they are trying to learn!

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.